Back to Blog

How to Win in a Buyer's Market When Buying a New Construction Home

Builder incentives are only the starting point. Here is how to negotiate harder, vet builders, avoid agent and lender steering, and spot a fake builder credit in today's buyer's market.

November 20, 2026Jennifer Beeston

A lot of buyers walk into a new construction community, see a list of incentives, and assume they're already winning. Not so fast. There is a whole game being played that most people never see unless they've been a mortgage lender for 20 years watching it happen around the country, or they're a real estate agent working with multiple builders every year. In most of the country, especially where there's a lot of new construction, it's a buyer's market, and that gives you power. I want to share my secrets so you can use that power to your benefit. I'm a working mortgage loan officer, and my team and I help clients get pre-approved, fully underwrite their loans, and answer their mortgage questions every single day.

Know Who the Sales Associate Works For

When you walk into new construction on your own, you'll meet with the builder's sales associate. They may be as sweet as can be, but let me be very clear: they work for the builder. That doesn't mean you can't make a deal. You can absolutely negotiate directly with the builder's sales associate. Just remember whose interests they represent.

Beware of Hidden Agent Incentives

Going in with a real estate agent who understands new construction can be fantastic, especially one who will tell you to steer clear of a bad builder. But here's something people don't realize: some agents get paid more depending on which builder they bring you to. We saw this recently, where an agent was going to earn 4% instead of the usual two or three percent because the builder was offering extra incentives for bringing in a client. Some builders even reward agents with additional bonuses the more homes they sell.

I'm not saying all real estate agents are bad. But if you love one community and your agent keeps pushing you toward another without explaining why, there could be a financial incentive behind it. Make sure your agent has your best interest at heart and that you're buying a home you genuinely love.

Research the Builder Like You're Marrying Them

Before you sign a contract on any new construction home, research that builder like you're going to marry them. Check the Better Business Bureau, Yelp reviews, and Google reviews. Go on Reddit and ask whether anyone has worked with that builder in your area. One of my favorite tricks is to Google the builder's name along with the words construction defect lawsuit.

People assume a new home will be perfect, but a little time on Instagram or TikTok, or a quick dig through the lawsuit records of America, will tell you that's not always true. Some builders are building beautiful homes that will stand the test of time. Others are putting together slop, selling it at a premium price, and leaving buyers to spend years fighting to get warranty claims honored. If you don't believe me, Google Indian tribe sues builder, Florida. It's a real page turner. New construction may look pretty and have that new house smell, but that doesn't guarantee it was built properly.

Don't Settle for the First Concession

Buyers often tell me the builder is offering $10,000 in concessions, and they think that's a great deal. In many markets, you can get more. Every builder's worst nightmare is having fully built, move-in-ready homes sitting on the lot. If you walk into a community with four or five homes for sale and some are already finished, that's your cue to negotiate and ask for more.

You Don't Have to Use Their Lender

Back in 2021 and 2022, when houses were selling like hot pancakes, builders really pressed buyers to use their in-house lender, and if you refused, they'd walk away. This is a different market. Have your own loan officer, not the builder's, in your corner.

Just in the last week, we've seen this play out with several clients. One client was told he wouldn't get any closing cost money unless he used the builder's lender, and even his real estate agent told him he had to go along with it. He held off for a couple of days, pushed to use his own lender, which was us, and the builder agreed to give him the money anyway. Another client negotiated directly with the builder without an agent. At first they gave her the same song and dance, offering a limited amount and insisting she use their lender. She held firm on the amount she wanted, how she wanted it written up, and which lender she wanted to use. Because she's a veteran, there were extra items she could ask for, and we walked her through them. Four days later, she was in contract with everything she wanted, working with Linda on my team, who is fantastic.

Spotting a Fake Builder Credit

Am I telling you to avoid the builder's lender just because I want your business? No. If the builder's lender is genuinely offering a better deal, that's great. Sometimes a builder really will offer a 3.99% rate. But many advertised promos come with fine print so restrictive that almost nobody qualifies, like a home that had to be built on one specific day before 4 p.m. Those teaser rates often aren't what you actually get. We always tell people to show us what the builder is offering, and if we can't beat it, we'll tell you it's a good deal.

What we see far too often is what I call a fake builder credit. The builder offers $20,000 toward closing costs, but when we look at the closing costs, there's $6,000 in lender fees for a rate that another loan officer could offer with zero fees. The builder owns the mortgage company, so they hand you money with one hand and put it back in their other pocket. It doesn't always happen, but I've seen it enough to warn people about it many times. And if the builder is giving you real money, you should be able to use it with any lender you choose, wherever you can get the best deal. You can negotiate for exactly that.

The Bottom Line

If you feel like you're being steered toward the builder's lender with no way out, I'm telling you as a mortgage loan officer licensed in 48 states who sees this every day: in this market, you can push back, use your own loan officer, and ask for more. Talk with your loan officer about what's allowed with your loan program. If you don't have one, I'd be happy to help at 786-933-2077. Whether you work with me or not, I hope you negotiate hard and get the best deal possible, because this market belongs to buyers.

Ready for next steps

Get a clear mortgage plan before you start shopping.

Apply now through Rate or schedule a time with the Beeston team for direct guidance.