Don't Toss Your Mortgage Mail: Your Escrow Analysis Could Contain a Check
Your annual escrow analysis can raise your mortgage payment or send you a refund check. Here is what to look for, what to do with a refund, and how to fight rising costs.
Your annual escrow analysis can raise your mortgage payment or send you a refund check. Here is what to look for, what to do with a refund, and how to fight rising costs.
Homeowners, please do not throw away your mail. You could be tossing out a real check without realizing it. I'm Jennifer Beeston, and I've been a mortgage lender for 20 years. Today I want to talk about escrow accounts and why you need to pay close attention to the emails and letters you get from your loan servicer. A few minutes of reading can save you from a budget shock, a late payment, or accidentally shredding money that belongs to you.
If you already own a home, a portion of your monthly mortgage payment may go toward your property taxes and homeowners insurance. That portion is held in what's called an escrow account. Not every mortgage has one, but a lot do, and many people like them because they make life easier. You don't have to wonder whether your tax bill is due or whether your insurance has been paid, because your servicer handles it for you.
If you don't have an escrow account, now is the time to check on things yourself. Are your taxes paid? Are you prepared to pay them? Depending on where you live, this is when a lot of tax bills come due. Make sure your tax bill is being paid and that your insurance is up to date.
For those of you with escrow accounts, this is the time of year when your mortgage servicer, the company you send your payment to every month, reviews your escrow account. In many states, they look at your most recent tax bill and what they paid for your insurance, and then they recalculate your escrow balance.
What does that mean for you? Your payment can change. It's that simple. If your property taxes went up or your homeowners insurance went up, your monthly payment will go up too. If those costs went down, your payment may go down.
Here's a real example. I bought a house last year and did my mortgage with Rate, which is where I work. About a week and a half ago, I received my escrow analysis. First, I got an email saying there were new updates to my escrow account. Then I received a mailed version that laid out all the payments I'd made, how much was paid for insurance, what the tax bill was, and what my new payment would be. It also said they would adjust my autopay to match.
Not every company automatically adjusts your autopay, and that matters. If your taxes or insurance have jumped and your autopay updates on its own, that higher payment could really shock your budget. If it doesn't update automatically, you need to stay on top of it so you don't end up with late mortgage payments.
When I went online to review my escrow analysis, I was surprised to see that my payment actually went down. I live in Florida, and everyone assumes bills in Florida only go up. Not this time. Mine went down.
Since I had already seen all of that online, I nearly ignored the next piece of mail. It looked like a normal letter from Rate, and I almost tossed it. Thankfully, I opened it. It was about my escrow account again, and inside was a check for $1,000. They had overcollected, so I was getting money back.
This happens more often than people realize. When escrow balances are recalculated, servicers have sometimes collected more than they needed, and the difference comes back to you. So pay attention to your mail. You'll either find out your payment is going up, or you'll find out it's going down and you have money coming your way. Either way, you do not want to tear up that check.
My recommendation really depends on where you live. If you're in California, I'd suggest putting that check in a savings account and waiting. California reassesses property taxes based on purchase price, and those reassessments often don't happen quickly enough, so there can be glitches. You don't want to spend money that you may end up owing later.
In most other states, a refund check is legitimate. Still, make sure you understand why you're getting it. Look at how your servicer calculated your taxes. If you see their numbers and think your taxes are actually much higher than that, put the check in savings until things are sorted out.
If your escrow rebalance shows your payment going up significantly, it's a good idea to call your servicer and understand why. Often the increase is driven by insurance. If that's the case, shop your homeowners insurance. I cannot recommend this enough. We've had clients call four other insurance companies and find a policy that was cheaper than what they had before, while their existing company was planning to raise their premium by $1,000 a year. It really does pay to shop around.
Property taxes can be trickier, but you should always review your tax bill when it arrives, no matter what state you're in. If it looks wrong or too high, you may be able to challenge it. I hear this from our Texas clients often. You won't be arguing with your mortgage lender, because they still have to collect what they believe you owe. Instead, you take it up with the actual property tax collector, and sometimes you can get it reduced. My sister lives in Seattle, and she does this every single year. They always try to raise her assessment to some astronomical amount, and as a former attorney, she pushes back and gets it lowered.
If you receive something that doesn't look right, or you aren't sure whether it's actually from your lender, reach out to your loan officer. If you worked with me and my team, just send us a text and we'll tell you if it's legitimate. Even if you didn't work with us, send it over, and nine times out of ten we can tell you whether it's spam. And if you need a loan officer, I'm here to help with all your mortgage needs.
Your escrow analysis is one of the most important pieces of mail you'll get as a homeowner. Read your emails, open your letters, and check whether your payment is going up or down. Shop your insurance if it's climbing, review your tax bill every year, and never throw away a check without knowing why it was sent. The last thing you want is a nasty surprise when your mortgage payment comes out in the next few months.
More guides
November 14, 2026
Motivated winter sellers, year-end tax goals, and builders clearing inventory create real bargains. Here's how to use an end-of-year closing to negotiate a better deal, plus the contract deadlines to hit.
November 13, 2026
Jumbo buyers are back, inventory is up, and sellers are holding firm. Here's how to negotiate price cuts, rate buydowns, and closing costs in today's Texas standoff.
November 5, 2026
Explore why buyers are considering South Carolina, with local insights on housing costs, jobs, buyer agreements, and seller concessions.
Ready for next steps
Apply now through Rate or schedule a time with the Beeston team for direct guidance.